Both Seventh Generation Free & Clear and All Free Clear are designed for sensitive skin — but they take very different approaches. One is plant-based and eco-focused. The other is dermatologist-endorsed and clinically proven. Here's how they actually compare for people with sensitive skin, eczema, or allergies.
Who Each One is For
- ✅ Clinical dermatologist recommendation
- ✅ Proven on eczema-prone skin
- ✅ Best for severe skin sensitivities
- ✅ More loads per dollar
- ✅ National Eczema Association accepted
- ✅ Eco-conscious households
- ✅ Plant-based ingredient priority
- ✅ EWG verified formula
- ✅ No synthetic additives
- ✅ Better environmental profile
Ingredients Compared
All Free Clear uses a conventional but clinically tested formula — no dyes, no fragrances, no optical brighteners. The surfactants are synthetic but specifically selected and tested to minimize skin irritation. The National Eczema Association has accepted it, which requires clinical evidence of safety for eczema-prone skin.
Seventh Generation Free & Clear uses plant-derived surfactants and enzymes. No synthetic fragrances, no dyes, no optical brighteners, EWG verified. The ingredient list is more transparent and the environmental impact is lower — but it hasn't been through the same clinical skin testing as All Free Clear.
Cleaning Performance
All Free Clear outperforms Seventh Generation on tough stains — the conventional surfactant system is simply more powerful. For everyday loads both perform similarly. For households dealing with heavy staining alongside sensitive skin, All Free Clear is the better choice. Seventh Generation is excellent for everyday laundry in eco-conscious households without heavy staining needs.
Value Comparison
All Free Clear wins on value decisively — 184 loads at 7.6 cents per load versus Seventh Generation at 24 cents per load. Over a year of weekly washing, that difference is meaningful. If budget matters, All Free Clear is the clear choice.
Our Verdict
🏁 Our Verdict
For sensitive skin, All Free Clear is our recommendation — it's clinically proven, dermatologist recommended, National Eczema Association accepted, and extraordinarily good value at 7.6 cents per load. Choose Seventh Generation if eco-friendly ingredients are equally important to you as skin safety and you're comfortable paying more per load for the greener formula.
⚠️ Affiliate disclosure: Links in this post are affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.